Success criterion 1.2.3
1.2.3 Audio Description or Media Alternative (Prerecorded)
When videos need a second narrative track.
1. What is the goal of this criterion?
A video without sound is hard to follow – but a video without picture can be downright impossible to understand for some people. For blind or visually impaired users, a lot of visual information is out of reach unless it’s described or conveyed some other way.
That’s why WCAG Success Criterion 1.2.3 requires that what a video shows is also available in words – either as audio description or as a detailed text version.
2. What exactly does it require?
For prerecorded synchronized media (typical videos with picture and sound), you have to provide one of two alternatives:
1. Audio description
An additional spoken narration that describes important visual information – for example what’s happening on screen, which gestures or expressions people show, or what the setting looks like.
- The description runs in the pauses between dialogue and fills in what the soundtrack leaves out.
- It’s particularly useful when the story is told largely through images (for example in training, explainer or documentary videos).
2. Media alternative in text form
A detailed written version of the entire video – similar to a screenplay. It contains:
- All dialogue and relevant sounds
- Descriptions of scenes, actions, expressions and settings
- The order of events – just like in the video
- Any calls to action, such as “Press the green button now”
Important: the text alternative doesn’t depend on the soundtrack, so it can be more detailed than an audio description and doesn’t have to fit into pauses.
The exception in the normative text: if the video is only a media alternative to existing text and is clearly labelled as such, no further alternative is needed. And in practice: if the spoken audio already conveys all important visual information, there’s nothing extra to describe.
3. Why does it matter for accessibility?
Imagine listening to a video in which someone says, “As you can see, the curve suddenly gets steep” – but you can’t see anything. Or someone says, “This is exciting” – and you have no idea what’s going on.
Audio descriptions and text alternatives make sure that:
- blind or visually impaired people get the same access to information as sighted users,
- all visual content can also be taken in by listening or reading,
- complex scenes become understandable – for example in training sessions, presentations or video tutorials,
- content works across several senses – which also helps people with learning or language barriers.
And they support inclusion through equivalence – not as a special solution, but as a natural part of media content.
4. How to meet the criterion
Which route is right depends on the format and purpose. Here’s how to implement both:
Audio description
- Use pauses between dialogue to convey important visual information briefly and precisely.
- Describe neutrally and concretely (“She points at the screen” rather than “We can see …”).
- Tools like YouDescribe or video editors with separate audio tracks help with the implementation.
- For complex videos, plan pauses from the start so there’s enough room for descriptions.
Text alternative
- Create a screenplay-style document that describes the action, scene changes, gestures, expressions and sounds.
- Add speaker names and visual context (for example [The speaker points at a chart with a rising line]).
- Provide the text right next to the video – as an HTML section on the same page or clearly linked.
- Keep the structure logical and clear – like a radio play script.
Which route gets you further?
If you provide audio description straight away, you also meet Audio Description (Prerecorded) at Level AA – the level usually required in practice. The text alternative alone is only enough for Level A, but it’s the basis for Media Alternative (Prerecorded) at Level AAA. Neither route replaces captions: those are covered by Captions (Prerecorded).
5. Why this criterion matters for businesses
Audio descriptions and text alternatives may look like a lot of effort at first – but they pay off: for inclusion, reach and reputation.
1. You reach more people
Blind and visually impaired people benefit, and so do people with cognitive disabilities. You open up content to audiences that would otherwise be excluded – according to the WHO, around 1.3 billion people worldwide live with a significant disability.
2. You improve the user experience
A text version can be skimmed and searched quickly, and audio description lets people follow a video without looking – handy for anyone who can’t keep their eyes on the screen all the time.
3. You strengthen your brand
Thinking and acting inclusively shows what you stand for. In education, the public sector and recruiting in particular, that sends a strong signal.
And then there’s the law: since 28 June 2025, the European Accessibility Act has applied to many consumer products and services; Germany implements it through the Barrierefreiheitsstärkungsgesetz (BFSG). The benchmark is EN 301 549, which refers to WCAG 2.1 Level AA – that includes 1.2.3 and, through 1.2.5, audio description as well. Public sector bodies have their own obligations. (General information, not legal advice.)
6. The success criterion in the W3C’s words
Success Criterion 1.2.3 Audio Description or Media Alternative (Prerecorded) (Level A)
An alternative for time-based media or audio description of the prerecorded video content is provided for synchronized media, except when the media is a media alternative for text and is clearly labeled as such.
In short: prerecorded videos with picture and sound need audio description or a full text alternative – unless the video is clearly labelled as an alternative to text.
Official explanation from the W3C
The W3C explains every success criterion in depth – with intent, examples and techniques.
Understanding 1.2.3 (opens in a new tab)